How to Sign In
Psychology Blog
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 
Bush's Service Dog: Loyal? Thinking Critically

Bush's Service Dog: Loyal? Thinking Critically

Scroll down the center of this box to see another point of view on the image of president Bush's dog:



  • Do any students have a dog (or have in the past) who they feel certain has displayed emotions like Sully?
  • What emotions are students confident that dogs can feel (Sadness? Guilt?) and which emotions do they think are probably too complex for dogs?

Not sure what to add to your MindTap course? Add this post for class discussion! No matter what Cengage text you're using, this article fits perfectly in the "Psychology as a Science" section.


How to add this post to your MindTap course
Login into MindTap


MindTap is included with Cengage Unlimited.


Animals do LOVE unconditionally and i DO believe they have feelings for their owners.  They sure make me feel LOVED and Special..Smiley Happy!


I agree, my cat grieved when my other cat died. It was so sad, as they were best buddies.

Valued Contributor

I am over Paideia instruction now at Rowan-Cabarrus (socratic seminar). This would work perfectly in a seminar where we were focused on visual arguments. 

Keep in mind that the point of the exercise is not to prove that animals do or not have feelings - the point is for students to understand that it's hard to study animal emotions because sometimes we are projecting our own feelings into them. Sometimes there are alternative, less complicated explanations for what we see.


An additional thing to mention about the Sully image: one has to wonder how this picture was taken - what was Sully doing before the photo? Did Sully decide to sit next to the casket or did someone in the room "think it would be cute" to get a picture of Sully next to the casket and so called Sully into the room and told here to lie down in that spot?

@Jenny_Billings I'm curious about Paideia, I found this link about Paideia, but can you briefly explain?