No matter what the prevailing discussion is in Washington, job creation remains perhaps the biggest challenge for policymakers. And many of the most ardent small business supporters argue that their sector is the real engine of job creation in the US. So jump-starting that engine would certainly be welcome. But it may be that small businesses started to change in size before the recession. That is, that they became smaller and had fewer employees. A new Kaufman Foundation report highlights this issue, and makes the case that a boost in small business job creation is highly dependent on the number of small businesses, and not so much on current small businesses hiring more people. Recent Census Bureau research has pointed to one factor that is contributing to this slowdown in job creation—shrinking job creation in startups. As shown in Figure 1, startups created an average of 3.5 percent of total U.S. jobs annually in the 1980s, but in the 2000s contributed only 2.6 percent of total U.S. jobs. While diminished in number, these jobs still were the difference between positive and negative overall net job growth in the United States. Media and academic commentators who bemoan America’s unusually slow rate of job creation after the 2007–2009 recession are missing what we believe is a longer-term trend that began earlier in the decade and might best be called a slow jobs “leak.” In the pages that follow, we draw upon newly available data to track businesses over time and dig deeper into the health of U.S. startups. We examine young companies’ size at birth, jobs created, and survival patterns to draw inferences about the health of emerging companies in the United States. The patterns we find among young businesses show that recent U.S. startups are performing much worse than prior cohorts in terms of job creation. Conventional wisdom about job growth tends to focus solely on the jobs that are being created at existing (typically big) companies. But as a wealth of recent research has shown,6 new businesses are vital contributors to a healthy jobs market. Indeed, we know that, until the Great Recession, new firms in the United States generated on average about 3 million new jobs every year. While these firms typically follow a quick up-or-out pattern of success or failure, our analysis highlights for further scrutiny of some additional and, we believe, significant facts about the jobs actually created by new businesses. Read Starting Smaller; Staying Smaller: America’s Slow Leak in Job Creation here .
Filed under: jobs, Small Business, kauffman foundation, recession, startups, recovery, employment, job growth, job creation, smaller small businesses, small business hiring