Jeremy Gerst and Daniel Wilson, both economists at the San Francisco Fed, have just published an Economic Letter in which they describe the struggles of state governments to make ends meet. And they share two telling graphs. First, a look at what happened to revenue when real GDP dropped:

And then a look at how spending changed (or rather, didn't) as revenue dropped:

The picture, Gerst and Wilson write, is not bound to look any prettier for some time:
All indications are that states will be struggling to move their budgets toward balance for quite some time. Recovery of state finances historically lags recovery of the national economy. Forecasters expect the national economy to recover gradually (see Weidner and Williams 2010). Thus, it will take quite a while before states see considerable improvement in their fiscal health. Indeed, estimates from the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities show significant state budget gaps persisting through at least 2012. And a recent Rockefeller Institute report noted that most states are uncertain when revenue will return to prerecession levels, indicating the problem could continue well beyond 2012 (see Boyd and Dadayan 2010).
In many respects, fiscal conditions are likely to get worse before they get better. Federal stimulus plan grants to state governments have helped states close budget gaps. However, federal stimulus funds are set to diminish in 2011 and all but disappear in 2012, leaving states to deal with their budget gaps without this federal support. Another factor that could worsen state budget problems is the depletion of rainy-day funds. At this point, even states that had rainy-day funds going into the recession have fully tapped them. Finally, some states have used accounting tricks to in effect kick the fiscal adjustment can down the road. Now these have largely been exhausted and the end of the road is in sight.
Read Fiscal Crises of the States: Causes and Consequences here.
Posted
06-29-2010 1:46 AM
by
Graham Griffith
Filed under: Stimulus, government spending, GDP, debt, taxes, revenue, state budgets, San Francisco Fed, daniel wilson, jeremy gerst, federal reserve bank of san francisco, public services, budget gaps, expenditures, costs, state budget crisis