When the Treasury introduced the Troubled Assets Relief Program late last year, the government guaranteed the values of hundreds of billions of dollars in bank assets. The move was made, to put it very simply, to prevent a panic and protect the assets of millions of American taxpayers. The Congressional Oversight Panel, in its November report, concludes that the federal guarantees did that successfully. But the report also shows that the guarantees now account for the "single largest element of the government's response to the financial crisis," and that raises some timely questions for Treasury:
These guarantee programs also created significant moral hazard.
Guarantees create price distortions and can lead market participants to
engage in riskier behavior than they otherwise would. In addition to
the explicit guarantees analyzed in the Panel's report, the
government's broader economic stabilization effort may have signaled an
implicit guarantee to the marketplace: the American taxpayer stands
ready to provide a financial backstop for certain markets and large
market players to avert possible economic collapse. To the degree that
investors, lenders and borrowers believe that such an implicit
guarantee remains in effect, moral hazard will continue to distort the
market.
The extraordinary scale of these guarantees, the significant risk to
taxpayers, and the corresponding moral hazard leads the Panel to
conclude that these programs should be subject to extraordinary
transparency. The Panel specifically identified the guarantee of
Citigroup assets under AGP -- the largest single guarantee offered to
date -- and strongly urges Treasury to provide regular, detailed
disclosures about the status of the assets backing up this guarantee.
Treasury should disclose greater detail about the rationale behind
guarantee programs, the alternatives that may have been available and
why they were not chosen, and whether these programs have achieved
their objectives. This should include an analysis of why Citigroup and
Bank of America were selected for AGP and not others.
Here is COP Chair Elizabeth Warren introducing the November report:
You can read the full report here.
Posted
11-10-2009 7:53 AM
by
Graham Griffith