Each
quarter the Duke University / CFO Magazine Global Business Outlook
Survey polls thousands of chief financial officers around the world.
The most recent survey concluded May 29 and reflects the views of
1,309 CFOs in the U.S., Europe, and Asia. This entry is by John R. Graham of Duke University's Fuqua School of Business, and CFO Magazine's Kate O'Sullivan.
We recently surveyed CFOs of 540 companies in the US, and
nearly 800 in Europe and Asia, to gauge the status of credit markets and the
world economy. About one quarter of companies has been severely impacted by
tight credit markets, and another third has been moderately affected. These
financially constrained companies are in a troubling position because they for
the most part have negative earnings and have seen their cash holdings shrink
on average by about one-fifth over the past year. Finding credit is difficult
for them, and when a loan can be secured, the interest rates and fees are
high.
If these financially constrained firms are losing money,
their cash is disappearing, and they can not borrow on favorable terms, what
can they do? More than 80 percent have had to postpone or cancel valuable
investment projects due to credit tightness. Half have sold assets just to fund
their remaining operations. When they do obtain funding, these companies draw
heavily on their bank credit lines, rather than using lines as short-term funds
or as a bridge as intended. For these companies, credit market conditions have
worsened during 2009, despite the historic efforts of the central bankers and
Treasury Department. Moreover, many of these firms indicate that they will need
to borrow before year-end, though it is not clear whether lenders will be
willing to provide them funds.
But not all companies are in such dire straights. Among the
40 percent of companies that say they have been largely unaffected by the
credit crisis-mainly those that have remained profitable and retained a good
credit rating-four out of five have found stable or improved credit conditions
during 2009. These stronger companies are able to borrow and the fees and rates
they pay have not increased. These firms have been able to build up their cash
reserves this year, and they are not leaning heavily on their available lines
of credit. While these companies are cautious about their hiring and capital
spending plans, the cuts they have made are not as severe as those at the
troubled firms. Overall, these strong companies have been able to tread water
as the economic turmoil has raged, and they are hunkered down and appear able
to ride out the rest of the storm. It is on the backs of these companies that
the economic recovery will ride when it starts.
The great risk for the economy, as we see it, is that the
liquidity crisis among troubled firms continues unabated, with the banking
system not willing to aid them, in large part because they are troubled. Should
this scenario play out, the second half of 2009 might be worse than the first
half.
But even for these weaker companies, one glimmer of hope is
that the majority have been able to negotiate more favorable terms (reduced
prices, delayed payments) with their suppliers. While helpful to the weak
firms, of course, this does shift some of the burden to their suppliers.
Two other pieces of good news. First, CFO optimism is up
from last quarter's record lows. While still below the long-run average
optimism, this leading indicator is moving in the right direction, which bodes
well for early 2010. The majority of CFOs say that they believe a recovery will
be underway as 2010 begins. Second, an internal recovery is occurring in Asia,
not dependent on the West. For example, in China, a majority of companies
report an increase in orders from other Chinese firms. With this important part
of the world economy stabilizing, export demand for goods produced in the US
and Europe should in time increase, aiding a 2010 recovery in the West.
John R. Graham is the D. Richard Mead Jr. Family Professor of Finance at Fuqua School of Business.
The Global Business Outlook Survey has been conducted 53 consecutive quarters. For more information on the survey click here.
Posted
06-04-2009 10:49 AM
by
Graham Griffith